Weekend Reading: TFSA Snowball Edition

Weekend Reading TFSA Snowball Edition

I’ve been toying with a savings concept that I’m tentatively calling the TFSA snowball. It’s a play on Dave Ramsay’s “debt snowball” method (his one positive contribution to society) where borrowers pay off their smallest loan balance first, then roll those freed-up payments into the next smallest balance. Rinse and repeat until debt free.

Related: I prefer the debt avalanche where you tackle the highest interest rate balance first.

While it’s rare for my clients to be that heavily indebted, many of them are striving to catch-up on unused TFSA contribution room. After all, money is finite and we can’t do everything all at once. Heck, my wife and I are on our third game of playing TFSA catch-up in the last 15 years!

Indeed, you might have a period of income interruption from a parental leave or career change. Maybe you financed a vehicle and had to temporarily pause TFSA contributions. Perhaps you just had other spending or saving priorities and the TFSA got neglected.

Whatever the case, the TFSA snowball concept is meant to treat your unused contribution room like a five-alarm emergency. That’s right, you’ll aggressively attack these contributions as if you were paying off high interest credit card debt. Within reason, you’re going to throw everything you have at your TFSA until you’ve caught up on all of that unused contribution room.

What’s the payoff? Well, it’s a similar feeling to paying off your consumer debt. All of the money you were allocating towards debt repayment can now be redirected towards savings goals. Same with the TFSA.

Once your TFSA is fully maxed out, you can only contribute the annual limit afterwards – which will feel like a modest amount compared to your previously aggressive contributions.

The extra cash flow is now freed-up to fund other goals, like a new car, dream vacation, extra mortgage payments, lifestyle creep, non-registered investments, etc. The choice is yours!

YearTFSA ContributionAdditional Cash Flow
2025$56,000 $0
2026$56,000 $0
2027$56,000 $0
2028$26,000 $30,000
2029$16,000 $40,000
2030$16,000 $40,000

*this chart presumes the annual TFSA limit increases by $500 in 2026 (to $7,500) and then again in 2029 (to $8,000)

The table above is our own TFSA snowball plan. Aggressive contributions of $28,000 per year (each) for the next three years, followed by a $13,000 contribution (each) in 2028 to fully max our TFSAs.

The payoff after three-and-a-half more years of TFSA catch-up is that we’d only have to contribute the annual limit from 2029 onwards and can redirect those extra catch-up contributions towards other goals.

Right now that’s loosely earmarked for the mortgage – extra lump sum payments to pay off the balance earlier. But the timing also coincides with our kids entering post-secondary years (yikes!) and so we might not want to commit all of those funds until we know exactly where the kids are going and what their funding requirements will be.

We could also simply pay ourselves less, since we topped-up our personal income to do the TFSA snowball in the first place.

Or, without the pressure to save more, we could decide to work a bit less and intentionally earn less income. Like a Coast Fire plan.

There’s also a vehicle purchase to consider – or some modest home renovations.

Who am I kidding? The funds will probably go towards enhancing our travel budget!

In summary, like an aggressive debt repayment plan, a conscious effort to catch-up on unused TFSA contribution room for a few years can dramatically improve your financial picture and give you a host of options to consider afterward.

What are your thoughts on treating your unused TFSA room like a five-alarm emergency? Let me know in the comments.

This Week’s Recap:

I’ve updated my annual reminder on how to crush your RRSP contributions next year by using the T1213 form to reduce withholding taxes at the source. This is a secret weapon for many of my higher-earning clients who contribute significantly to their RRSP each year. Why not get your tax refund upfront on every paycheque instead of waiting until you file your taxes?

Last week I wrote about lifestyle creep not necessarily being a bad thing.

We’re off to our favourite city in the world – Edinburgh – next week for a 10-day holiday. It’ll be our fourth time back to “the most beautiful of all the capitals of Europe.” We can’t wait!

“This is a city of shifting light, of changing skies, of sudden vistas. A city so beautiful it breaks the heart again and again.” – Alexander McCall Smith

Weekend Reading:

If you’re still working and contributing to CPP, or if you’re retired and still waiting to take CPP, your expected CPP benefits increase based on wage inflation. But if you’re already receiving CPP benefits, your annual increase is based on price inflation.

Typically, wage inflation is about 1% higher than price inflation. But that was not the case in 2022 when prices rose faster than wages. That year, Fred Vettese pointed out, was an anomaly where you would have been better off taking CPP in December instead of January so you’d benefit from the price inflation bump instead of the wage inflation bump.

Complicated stuff, right? So what about this year? Fred Vettese is back to answer that question now that the data is out

Of Dollars and Data blogger Nick Maggiulli is doing the lord’s work busting the persistent myth that Vanguard, BlackRock, and State Street are a secret cabal that control the world.

Here’s what football (soccer) fans can teach investors:

“One of the biggest behavioural challenges fans and investors face is the tendency to overreact. Fans often make snap judgments, calling for managerial changes or criticising players after just one bad game. Investors, too, can fall into the trap of panic-selling during a market downturn or impulsively chasing after the latest “hot” stock, fund or theme.”

How do people react to financial advice? It depends on who is receiving it, who is giving it, and what it consists of.

Money Architect’s Russell Sawatsky tackles a thorny issue for DIY investors – at what age do you hand over the reigns?

Will buying a home make you happier? The evidence is mixed, at best:

A Wealth of Common Sense blogger Ben Carlson answers a reader question about whether they need five years of cash reserves in retirement.

Here’s Carlson again discussing the perils of planning for early retirement:

“Your two best forms of risk management in retirement are diversification and flexibility with your plan. Every strategy comes with trade-offs. Unfortunately, there is no investment panacea that offers 100% certainty during retirement.”

Finally, here’s Jason Heath with the ins and outs of consolidating your registered accounts for retirement income.

Happy Thanksgiving, and have a great weekend!

9 Comments

  1. Ravi on October 12, 2024 at 5:15 pm

    Hey Robb,

    You are the only person I know who’s saved their full contribution limit of a TFSA to then spend it and do it again (and again).

    That definitely is a tactic I’ve never considered – would the growth in just filling it up and leaving it in your standard VEQT to acrue gains be a better option than emptying and restarting?

    Also, that Dave Ramsey joke made me laugh out loud.

    Enjoy Scotland!

    • Robb Engen on October 12, 2024 at 6:21 pm

      Hey Ravi, thanks! I mean, of course we would be better off financially if we still had our original TFSA money intact and maxed out our contributions each year.

      But financial well being and overall well being are two different things. We wouldn’t have this house we’re in now, for instance, which has contributed greatly to our overall happiness and life satisfaction.

      Watching the numbers grow on a spreadsheet or in a brokerage account could make me happy, too, but not to the same degree.

      And yeah, Dave Ramsey is not a good person.

      Cheers!

  2. Jill S on October 12, 2024 at 5:43 pm

    I feel like you’re still being very logical about the TFSA so maybe a 4-alarm fire? Or maybe we just did DEFCON 1 or something else because we went from practically nothing in TFSAs to maxed out full contributions in two years (tell me you were sitting on too much cash in analysis paralysis without telling me …).

    Okay, the real question though: Edinburgh? It is definitely a beautiful city but I found it heavily reinforced my hatred of the Victorians and other tourists. I want to hear more about the magic I maybe just couldn’t see through all those tacky shops and ghost tours.

    • Robb Engen on October 12, 2024 at 6:28 pm

      Hi Jill, that’s true – this is a logical approach so it’s not quite a “hair on fire” emergency in the way that credit card debt would be. Fair point!

      I like the DEFCON1 approach. Maybe we just need different degrees of the snowball, sort of like how there are 18 different FIRE types.

      As for Edinburgh, well you need to step off the Royal Mile to truly experience the magic. I mean, Calton Hill, Arthur’s Seat, Dean Village – these are all INSIDE the city!

      Don’t go in August for Fringe festival and the military tattoo if you want to avoid tourists.

      We’ve been in mid-June, mid-July, late July (ramping up for fringe but not quite the madness), and now mid-October.

      I would say to avoid the tacky tourist shops and ghost tours in ANY major city – that’s a given. Spend some time off the beaten path and with the locals and that’s where the magic is discovered.

  3. Mark H on October 12, 2024 at 6:27 pm

    The math for us has infected and is now saying that RRSP > TFSA, so maxing TFSA every year has been less of a priority. What about for you guys?

    • Robb Engen on October 12, 2024 at 6:32 pm

      Hi Mark, that’s a good point – it’s different for everyone.

      Our RRSPs are maxed and now we pay ourselves dividends from our business (which does not generate new RRSP room) so we’re stuck between filling up our TFSAs and investing inside our corp (we do both).

      In your case it might be an RRSP snowball to catch up on unused room over a few years. We did that for a period of time.

  4. Brian N on October 13, 2024 at 1:18 pm

    My wife and I went on an eight day Scottish tour in August. The tour ended in Edinburgh. We loved walking around the city but it was too short. We hope to return someday soon. Enjoy your trip.

  5. Diane on October 17, 2024 at 9:58 am

    I am retired and therefore have limited ability to contribute to my TFSA. However, I have investments which are not in an RRSP or a TFSA. I have been transferring-in-kind each year to max out my TFSA. It is much better to have the income generated inside the TFSA rather than out thanks to the tax-free growth. My TFSA is also my emergency fund, as taking money from my TFSA does not have any tax consequences. One thing to remember is that if you are transferring-in-kind, do it only with something that will result in a capital gain (no matter how small, make sure it is a gain). If you transfer-in-kind with something that would normally result in a capital loss, you do not get to use that capital loss on your tax return. It is forfeited.

  6. Gary on November 2, 2024 at 6:25 pm

    Edinburgh is OK, Budapest is a gem

Leave a Comment





Join More Than 10,000 Subscribers!

Sign up now and get our free e-Book- Financial Management by the Decade - plus new financial tips and money stories delivered to your inbox every week.