Weekend Reading: Testing Investors’ Mettle Edition

Weekend Reading Testing Investors' Mettle Edition

Stock markets around the world are testing investors’ mettle. The tech-heavy NASDAQ is down 20%, dipping officially into bear market territory. NVIDIA stock, mired in scandal, is in free fall, down nearly 50% since the beginning of October.

Most of my clients smartly diversify into global equities, using a risk-appropriate asset allocation ETF. The all-equity VEQT is down 9.5% – closing in on a technical correction for the second time this year (remember, this also happened in March). The 80/20 growth version (VGRO) is down 7.5% over the same time frame.

For my retired or soon-to-be retired clients, this is where the cash wedge comes in handy. A 10% allocation inside a high interest savings ETF (ex. CASH or CBIL) can help facilitate withdrawals when markets suddenly get choppy around the time you need money.

One client wrote:

“It’s a great feeling when market losses show up in our various accounts, knowing we’ve got appropriate amounts of CASH set aside for just such situations. It’s down to our relationship with you, and confidence in what we’ve learned.”

It’s maybe not optimal to hold a chunk of cash in your portfolio, especially when stock markets are soaring higher. But retired investors are not emotionless robots.

It’s a hard enough transition to turn off the savings taps and turn on the spending taps. Good luck selling stocks when they’re down just because your plan says to withdraw $20,000 before year-end.

The cash wedge is a behavioural trick to address this very problem. 90% of your portfolio stays fully invested in your risk-appropriate asset allocation ETF. 10% stays parked in a HISA ETF.

Then I use simple caveman language as a framework to guide your withdrawal decisions:

Caveman voice.

“Market up, sell stocks. Market down, sell cash.”

Of course, because if stocks are up then your allocation will have naturally drifted to, say, 92% equities and 8% cash. Great! Sell some stocks.

If markets are down for a stretch, as they have been recently, your portfolio might have 88% stocks and 12% cash. Sell the cash and get back into that 90/10 balance.

This framework is perfect for accounts with expected withdrawals (RRSP/RRIF, LIF, even non-registered accounts). As a planner, I want you to make those RRSP withdrawals because we’re targeting a certain taxable income and average tax rate.

The cash wedge helps ensure you make those withdrawals, regardless of market conditions, so you can maintain your tax efficiency.

Forgoing the withdrawals means either decreasing your standard of living or else taking funds from other non-taxable sources like a TFSA or your savings account – which seems fine today but likely creates higher taxable income in the future.

This Week’s Recap:

In my last post I compared a financial plan generated by a bank branch versus a real financial plan from an advice-only planner. We’re talking about a difference of tens, if not hundreds of thousands of dollars over your lifetime.

Lately I’ve been speaking with clients about donating to charity and specifically about donating appreciated securities from a taxable account rather than selling them and donating the cash.

You receive the same charitable donation tax credit while eliminating the capital gains tax that would be otherwise payable on the unrealized gain. That’s right, the charity gets the full market value of the shares, you get the full charitable tax credit, and you don’t pay any capital gains tax on the accrued gain. Win, win, win.

I’ve spoken enough about this with clients that my wife and I decided to do it ourselves. We donated appreciated shares of VEQT to our local community foundation and established a Donor-Advised Fund to support several local charities that we donate to regularly anyway.

We’re looking forward to adding to this fund over the years and getting our whole family involved when it comes time to choose which charities we want the fund to support.

Weekend Reading:

Ivey Business School is inviting women across Canada to take part in a study on financial planning – the kind of research that can change how women save, invest, and feel about money for generations to come.

Anita Bruinsma says don’t let fears of a big stock market decline derail your investments.

Here’s Millionaire Teacher Andrew Hallam on young investment snowballs:

“Hot stocks are like a Knock-a-Mole game at an amusement park. Different heads keep popping up. So instead of playing the game with a little hammer, we can hit every mole when we slap down a large slab of plywood. That plywood represents a global stock ETF.

But most people, including most professional investors, insist on playing with the little hammer. And that limits their success, as they miss many of the winning stocks.”

For those sitting in cash waiting for a “better time”: Daniel Crosby on why the time will never be just right.

Aaron Hector shares what he’ll be proposing to the federal government in their RRSP for Life consultation.

Ben Felix shares how he invests his own money and where his views on money come from:

Here’s Dan Haylett on the retirement guilt gap: when you’ve got more than enough money to spend, but spending it still makes you feel like you’ve done something wrong.

Misconceptions about life expectancy are leading Canadians to underestimate how long they’ll live, with serious implications for financial planning.

Of Dollars and Data blogger Nick Maggiulli takes on the dangers of sports betting and predictions markets.

Finally, here are some true tales from Canada’s new “anywhere-but-America” snowbirds.

Have a great weekend, everyone!

Leave a Comment